Hello Rob
Lately I’ve been watching the NME reviews in the last 2 years (since they changed their website, newspaper and rating scale).
And I think the NME is not like the 2000s or 1990s and I think its weight should not be like other magazines like Pitchfork.
I think you should lower your weight to a normal magazine with a normal weight.
What do you think, Rob?
It’s probably worth thinking about.
How do you guys feel? Should all publications be weighted equally?
I think that NME in last few year 2015-2017
no serious review in comparation with other magazine P4k Spin
I don’t have a strong opinion about the weighting of reviews, but I think the rating scale from NME should be changed since they do 0-5 star reviews now.
Yes change system rating
This has been updated now, sorry for dragging my feet on it.
Perfect example are
http://www.albumoftheyear.org/publication/9-nme/perfect/
I think that NME with normal wight (Allmusic, DIY)
The difference for Sheer Mag is +0.1121 points due to weighting.
I’m sure Everything Now will even out once more reviews are added.
However, I’m still considering removing weights from any publication.